With the childcare market under scrutiny, James Hempsall OBE explains how settings can strengthen their finances, price confidently and build sustainable business models…
The Competition and Markets Authority has launched its study into early years education and childcare services in England. It’s set out a scope that reaches well beyond so-called “hidden charges”.
The sector is once again under scrutiny. However, it also has an important opportunity to explain how early education and childcare really works.
For providers already navigating rising staffing costs, expanded funded hours, and increasingly complex parental expectations, the question is no longer simply how to stay afloat.
It’s how to stay sustainable, transparent, and competitive in a sector where every financial decision made is being examined.
To do that, settings need to understand the new economics of early years and reshape business models accordingly.
The market study’s scope includes:
Transparency is now a strategic business tool. The CMA study is a clear signal: parents and policymakers want clarity.
This is not only about additional charges, but about the wider relationship between funding, affordability, access, quality and sustainability.
Settings know the reality. Meals, consumables, enrichment activities, extended hours, SEND support, leadership time and workforce development all carry unavoidable costs.
The opportunity now is to lead with transparency rather than wait for external pressure to dictate it. In practical terms that means creating a simple, jargon-free breakdown of what funding covers and what it doesn’t.
Costed examples can show the difference between funded rates and delivery costs. One-page explainers for new families can set out which items are optional, which are essential to the model, and how decisions are made.
When parents understand the economics, they are far more supportive of reasonable, clearly communicated charges.
A financially resilient setting is one that prices with confidence and evidence, not fear. Many settings still price emotionally, worried about parent reaction, local competition, or the optics of raising fees.
But underpricing is the fastest route to instability, especially when funded hours expand and margins can shrink.
I believe the sector must stop apologising for charging sustainably. High-quality early education is a skilled, labour-intensive service. It cannot be delivered on a deficit.
Too many providers our team works with do not fully calculate the true cost per hour, including non-contact time, training, SEND support, occupancy patterns, consumables, administration and leadership overheads.
Sometimes these are underestimated and sometimes over-inflated. The advice is to model three scenarios: break-even, sustainable surplus, and growth.
Most definitely we should review fees annually in September, not reactively mid-year, and keep a clear evidence base that explains how the decisions made have been reached.
Staffing is everyone’s biggest cost, and biggest opportunity. With wages rising and recruitment still challenging, it’s the single most important business decision to make.
The settings that thrive this year will treat staffing not as a cost to minimise, but as a strategic investment.
Focus on staff turnover is important, because it is more expensive than retention, every time. I like micro-retention strategies such as paid induction days, mentoring, and protected non-contact time.
A stable team reduces unnecessary agency spend, improves occupancy, and strengthens parent trust, all of which directly supports financial resilience.
Have you ever calculated the cost of losing a staff member, including agency cover, induction time, and lost continuity?
Occupancy management is the new superpower. In a world of expanded funded hours, occupancy is no longer just about filling spaces; it’s about filling the right spaces at the right times.
A room that looks full on paper may still be financially inefficient if the pattern of attendance creates staffing peaks and troughs.
Analyse occupancy by hour, not by day, identify “dead zones”, and create targeted offers to fill those gaps, such as short-session bundles or parent-toddler transition sessions.
Even small shifts in occupancy patterns can add thousands of pounds to annual revenue without increasing staffing levels.
Diversify income but do it transparently. With scrutiny now extending across information, choice, affordability and market practices, diversification must be both transparent and genuinely value-adding.
Parents are willing to pay for enrichment when they understand what they are getting, why it is optional, and how it sits alongside funded entitlement.
There are lots of models and ideas such as forest school or outdoor learning programmes, holiday clubs, stay-and-play sessions, parent workshops, or renting space to community groups.
The key here is clarity: optional, clearly priced, clearly communicated, and never presented in a way that leaves families uncertain about what is required and what is additional.
Communicate your value with confidence, because parents are not just choosing childcare; they are choosing early education, emotional security, and developmental expertise.
In a climate where information and choice are central to the CMA’s review, the settings that thrive will be those that articulate their value openly and proudly.
Make the time to share impact stories: progress data, parent testimonials, and staff expertise. Use September inductions to tell families about your curriculum and pedagogy.
Help your team to speak confidently about what makes your setting exceptional. When parents understand the value, they better understand the cost they are asked to pay.
A final thought. The early years sector is essential infrastructure. Financial fragility helps no one: not children, not families, not staff, and not the wider community.
Settings have a unique opportunity to lead the conversation while the CMA’s market study is underway. By embracing transparency, pricing sustainably, investing in staff, understanding local demand, evidencing costs, and communicating value with clarity, early years providers can build a business model that is both resilient and respected.
James Hempsall OBE is managing director of Coram Hempsall’s.